Country Experiences on Science-Based Approach to Highly Hazardous Pesticides

On 1 September, CropLife Africa Middle East held a webinar on the roadmap to achieving Target A7 of the Global Framework on Chemicals (GFC) on HHPs in Africa Middle East, where representatives from South Africa, Kenya and Ghana authorities and CLI shared their experiences.

With the first International Chemicals Conference (ICC1) taking place in Geneva this November, the discussion offered an important message: there is no one-size-fits-all solution. Countries are already developing practical tools to manage risks while taking farmers’ needs, local conditions and the availability of alternatives into account.

🇿🇦 South Africa applies a science-based, risk-informed approach aligned with the FAO/WHO HHP framework. Restricted agricultural remedies can be limited to designated persons, while a derogation process for substances of concern allows authorities to consider additional risk-assessment evidence where appropriate.

🇰🇪 Kenya reviewed all pesticide active ingredients, following a petition submitted to Parliament, and conducted public consultations on regulatory decisions. Kenya’s regulator, in collaboration with stakeholders, is focusing on stronger communication with farmers on the proper use of pesticides, re-evaluation guidelines, and a fast-track pathway for lower-risk products, including biologicals. Kenya is also working closely with EAC Partner States to develop guidelines for identifying HHPs and to ensure that effective and affordable alternatives are available.

🇬🇭 Ghana identified 22 active ingredients meeting HHP criteria, and assessed risks in the Ghanaian context, considering alternatives and farmers’ needs, and developing mitigation measures in collaboration with industry. The experience with aluminium phosphide illustrates how targeted restrictions, licensing and monitoring can help address significant risks while maintaining a focus on practical risk management.

What lessons emerge?
·      Science- and risk-based decisions, rather than blanket bans
·      Product-by-product and context-specific assessment
·      Progressive transitions, giving farmers time and support to adapt in line with Target A7
·      Effective risk mitigation and monitoring to verify that measures work in practice
·      Stronger collaboration between agriculture, environment and health authorities in countries
·      Enhanced regional cooperation
·      Faster access to low risk alternatives
·      Strong action against illicit trade, ensuring restricted products do not move into informal markets

Africa is already building a toolbox for managing HHP risks. The opportunity ahead of the GFC is to share and learn from these experiences. The goal is to manage risks effectively, support farmers through the transition, and ensure that safer, effective alternatives are available.